
How to evaluate an SEO proposal: scope, KPIs and realistic expectations
Buy a verifiable plan, not a promised ranking
A useful SEO proposal connects business priorities to target pages, explains the obstacles, defines the changes to be delivered and shows how progress will be checked. Before signing, agree the scope, exclusions, access and reporting measures. An agency can commit to delivery and transparent reporting. It cannot guarantee a Google ranking or a volume of sales. Ask for clarification when a quote contains only «optimisation» and «higher rankings».
If you are selecting an SEO agency for business, start with the commercial decision: which services or products matter, which market you serve and what makes an enquiry qualified. A company in Moldova serving Romanian and Russian speakers needs language-specific pages and query research. A business targeting a particular EU country needs evidence for that country rather than an assumption that Europe is one search market.
Make the proposals comparable
Give every candidate the same website, priority services, languages and planning period. A recommendation-only engagement and a service that includes implementation are different purchases. When reviewing SEO services for your business, ask where research ends and writing, development and verification begin.
| Workstream | Ask to see | Acceptance check |
|---|---|---|
| Baseline review | Issues with example URLs and priorities | The impact and next actions are understandable |
| Research and structure | Query groups, buyer intent and destination pages | Pages have distinct purposes rather than duplicate intent |
| Technical changes | Tasks, implementation owner and test criteria | Changes are live and checked again |
| Content | Page list, briefs, authors and approval process | Copy helps a buyer decide and matches verified facts |
| Measurement | Data sources, events and a sample report | Each conclusion can be traced to evidence |
A preliminary conversation need not include a complete unpaid audit. It should still explain the method, deliverables and how priorities will be chosen. Ask which assumptions require access to Search Console, analytics or the sales team before they can be tested. A responsible proposal makes those uncertainties visible.
Separate recommendations from implementation
«Fix technical errors» is not a testable deliverable. For a duplicate URL, someone needs to establish the preferred page, review internal links and language relationships, choose an appropriate remedy, implement it and inspect the resulting response and HTML. An improved audit-tool score does not replace these checks. Ask who owns each step, including the final validation.
- Who edits the CMS, and is development included in the fee?
- Who approves redirects, page removal and changes to the site structure?
- How are the previous state and a rollback route recorded?
- What evidence closes a task in the report?
Separate one-off setup, recurring work and additional costs. Expert writing, translation, development, software and agreed external placements may have different budgets. Do not assume they are included. If your team cannot release changes quickly, the plan should account for that dependency before work starts. A list of recommendations sitting in a document is not the same as a changed website.

Use a measurement ladder
Measure three layers: work delivered, search visibility and commercial outcomes. Record the source, baseline, segment and limitations for each measure. Total traffic alone can conceal the real story: informational visits or searches for your own brand may increase while discovery of a priority service remains flat.
| Layer | Useful measure | What it does not prove |
|---|---|---|
| Delivery | Priority changes implemented and verified | That Google has reassessed them |
| Visibility | Impressions and clicks for relevant non-brand queries | That every visitor is ready to buy |
| Enquiries | Received forms and verified calls | That every contact is commercially suitable |
| Quality | Qualified opportunities and sales recorded in CRM | That SEO alone caused the result |
Consider an illustrative scenario, not a client result: search clicks increase, but qualified enquiries do not. Check which pages gained visits, whether their offer matches the query and whether the contact process works. Connecting the website to a CRM can help follow an enquiry beyond form submission. Agree attribution rules and consent-related reporting limitations; different systems will not necessarily count the same journey identically.

Discuss timelines as conditions, not certainty
A delivery deadline and a search outcome are different things. An agency can publish a change on an agreed date; crawling, indexing and ranking changes depend on the search engine. A new domain and an established site have different starting points. Competition, seasonal demand, the strength of the offer and your approval process also affect what can be observed.
Ask for a first-stage plan with review points: access and baseline, diagnosis, priority agreement, implementation and validation. Then agree when the plan should be revised. A forecast should state assumptions and scenarios rather than promise an unconditional number of leads. If demand for a service has not been established, query research and the destination page deserve attention before a growth forecast.
Google's guidance on hiring an SEO recommends examining the provider's approach and transparency and warns against guaranteed first-place rankings. Claims of a special relationship with Google, secret methods or bulk low-quality links should trigger further questions. A higher score in a third-party tool is also not a guarantee of business growth.
Read reports as a decision tool
A monthly report should answer four questions: what changed, what was observed, what the team thinks it means and what happens next. Ask for links to released pages and completed tasks as well as charts. When performance falls, a segmented investigation and a testable explanation are more useful than automatically blaming an algorithm update.
A useful example of reporting language is: «Two service pages were revised and their forms tested. Visibility for the selected query group changed, but lead-quality data is still limited. The next step is to match enquiries with CRM outcomes.» It separates action, observation and uncertainty. «Everything is improving» offers little help in deciding the next budget.
- A comparable reporting period with a note on seasonality.
- Separate views for priority languages, markets and services.
- Implemented changes and unresolved dependencies.
- Enquiry quality alongside search measures.
- Next actions with named owners and acceptance criteria.
For low-volume services, a single month's movement can be noisy. Keep the chosen definitions consistent, look at a suitable longer period and avoid changing the target every time a chart fluctuates. Use the report to decide whether to continue a hypothesis, investigate it or move effort elsewhere.
Check ownership and handover before signing
Your business should retain control of its domain, website, Search Console and analytics accounts. Grant only the access required for the current stage, and agree responsibility for changes. Record what will be handed over at the end of the engagement, how access is withdrawn and who keeps the task history, research and editable content.
Whether you want to hire an SEO agency in Moldova or appoint a partner for another market, send candidates the same short brief. Ask them to identify priority pages, define the first stage, state exclusions, explain the resources they need from your team and provide a sample report. Compare clarity and verifiability rather than the length of the activity list.
Before approval, have written goals, deliverables, implementation responsibilities, a budget with exclusions, access rules, reporting definitions and an exit process. If one part is missing, request an amendment. This gives both sides a fair way to evaluate the service while search outcomes are still developing.
Discuss your website's SEO priorities
Send your website URL, priority services, languages and target markets. We can discuss the starting data, scope of the first stage and how to evaluate delivery.
Discuss SEO
